If The Dark and The Wicked left you sleeping with the lights on, you’re not alone. This movie isn’t your average horror flick—it’s a masterclass in psychological dread and supernatural terror, leaving you shaken long after it ends. If you’re craving more films that deliver that same gut-wrenching, slow-burn unease and chilling atmosphere, you’ve come to the right place. We’ve rounded up 10 movies like The Dark and the Wicked that will keep you on edge, make you question your own sanity, and—most importantly—haunt you for days. Buckle up!
1. Hereditary (2018)
“I am your mother!” – Annie (Toni Collette)
When Toni Collette yells that line, you know things are about to get really uncomfortable. Hereditary brings family trauma to a whole new level, and much like The Dark and the Wicked, it’s a perfect storm of grief, guilt, and creeping dread. Think you’ve had a bad day? Wait until you witness the decapitation scene—you’ll be rethinking that whole “it could be worse” mantra.
2. The Witch (2015)
“Wouldst thou like to live deliciously?” If you’ve seen The Witch, you know exactly what I’m talking about. Set in a desolate 17th-century farm, this one oozes the same isolated, hopeless vibe as The Dark and The Wicked. Bonus points for the creepy goat named Black Phillip. He might just be the least helpful farm animal in cinematic history. Seriously, if your goat starts talking, it’s time to move.
3. The Babadook (2014)
“If it’s in a word, or it’s in a look, you can’t get rid of the Babadook.”
Looking for a monster that’s less about jumps and more about psychological terror? Enter the Babadook. This film deals with grief and mental illness in a way that will leave you questioning your sanity (and whether your house is harboring any evil spirits). The Babadook doesn’t knock on your door; he just makes himself at home in your head. Try sleeping after that.
4. The Autopsy of Jane Doe (2016)
“You know, I don’t think this is just a murder case.”
If The Dark and the Wicked made you question whether your house was hiding something sinister, The Autopsy of Jane Doe asks the same thing but in a morgue. Two coroners (father and son) uncover some real strange things while autopsying the body of an unknown woman.
Let’s just say… things go downhill fast. What starts as a simple case turns into a terrifying mystery that will make you second-guess even your own reflection. The ending? Prepare to have your mind blown.
5. The Blackcoat’s Daughter (2015)
“You’re gonna want to watch out for the girl with the black coat.”
The Blackcoat’s Daughter is a slow-burn horror that has all the grim, eerie atmosphere of The Dark and the Wicked. Set in a desolate boarding school over winter break, it follows two girls—one struggling with her own personal demons, the other possibly dealing with something far worse.
The scenes of isolation and creeping dread are perfectly executed, making you question if anyone is really alone in this world. The eerie feeling builds and builds until you realize the real horror was lurking inside the characters all along. A definite mind-bender!
6. The Ritual (2017)
“What is that thing?” – Luke (Rafe Spall)
If you thought The Dark and the Wicked was the pinnacle of family-based fear, then you need to see The Ritual. This one’s got a bunch of college friends hiking through the creepy Swedish wilderness, only to stumble into something way worse than bad cell service.
Think The Blair Witch Project meets The Wicker Man, with a touch of ancient Norse mythology thrown in. The moment when the group first encounters the massive tree-like creature is enough to make you rethink your weekend camping trips. Trust me—stay home and watch horror films instead.
7. Midsommar (2019)
“No, no, no, no, no, no, no.” – Dani (Florence Pugh)
You know a movie is messed up when it’s set during the sunniest time of the year and still manages to make you feel uncomfortable. If you liked the feeling of dread in The Dark and the Wicked, Midsommar is here to provide that plus a cult, a bunch of unsettling rituals, and the world’s most awkward family vacation. Bonus points for Florence Pugh’s amazing acting and a level of discomfort that will make you question everything. Don’t let the sun fool you—it’s not safe.
8. Antichrist (2009)
“Chaos reigns.” – He (Willem Dafoe)
If The Dark and the Wicked made you nervous about living in the country, Antichrist is here to turn that fear into full-blown panic. This one’s less about the family dynamic and more about an existential nightmare. Seriously, don’t expect this to be a pleasant viewing experience. From the opening scene (which is… intense) to the final shocker, this one’s not for the faint of heart. But hey, if you’re into it, it’ll make you rethink any upcoming forest trips.
9. Saint Maud (2019)
“I’m here to save you.” – Maud (Morfydd Clark)
If you enjoy a slow, simmering feeling of dread mixed with religious fervor, Saint Maud is your jam. Maud is a deeply devout nurse who believes it’s her mission to save her patient’s soul… but the patient isn’t having it. The movie’s got all the psychological horror vibes of The Dark and the Wicked, plus a great dose of “Is she crazy, or is she being driven to madness by something else?” By the time you hit the final act, you’ll be asking, “What just happened?!” Spoiler: It’s a lot.
10. Martyrs (2008) (French Version)
“You don’t understand what she’s been through.”
Forget everything you thought you knew about horror—Martyrs will shatter those expectations and leave you reeling. This French nightmare doesn’t just rely on shock tactics; it digs deep into your psyche and rips apart your emotional core.
Much like The Dark and the Wicked, Martyrs lingers in your mind long after the credits roll, leaving you disturbed, haunted, and profoundly unsettled. The plot follows two young women seeking vengeance while unraveling the horrific secrets of a sadistic cult—but believe me, that’s just the surface. The real horror lies in what they uncover. And that final twist? It will completely dismantle your understanding of suffering and humanity.
Brace yourself—this shit (pardon my language, but seriously, I’m still flabbergasted by this film) is raw, brutal, and unrelenting. It’s not just a horror movie; it’s an emotional and psychological gut-punch that will make you question everything you thought you knew about suffering. Martyrs doesn’t just disturb you—it breaks you. Don’t say I didn’t warn you.
Final Thoughts
Whether it’s the oppressive atmosphere, the deep dive into grief, or the sheer terror of something evil closing in, these movies like The Dark and The Wicked will scratch that horror itch. Each film brings its unique twist, but they all share that unnerving, “I-shouldn’t-have-watched-this-alone” energy. So grab some popcorn (and maybe a nightlight), and let the nightmares begin!
Have you seen any of these? Or got other faves that give off The Dark and The Wicked vibes? Let me know in the comments below! 🎥👻
